next up previous
Next: New Equivalence Principle Up: Classical Motion of a Previous: Equations of Motion

Nonholonomic Mapping to Spaces with Torsion

It is possible to map the x-space locally into a q-space via an infinitesimal transformation

  equation464

with coefficient functions tex2html_wrap_inline3938 which are not integrable in the sense of Eq. (22), i.e.,

  equation470

Such a mapping will be called nonholonomic. It does not lead to a single-valued function tex2html_wrap_inline3922 . Nevertheless, we shall write (25) in analogy to (22) as

  equation478

since this equation involves only the differential tex2html_wrap_inline3942 . Our departure from mathematical conventions will not cause any problems.

From Eq. (25) we see that the image space of a nonholonomic mapping carries torsion. The connection tex2html_wrap_inline3944 has a nonzero antisymmetric part, called the torsion tensor:gif

  equation491

In contrast to tex2html_wrap_inline3946 , the antisymmetric part tex2html_wrap_inline3948 is a proper tensor under general coordinate transformations. The contracted tensor

  equation501

transforms like a vector, whereas the contracted connection tex2html_wrap_inline3950 does not. Even though tex2html_wrap_inline3924 is not a tensor, we shall freely lower and raise its indices using contractions with the metric or the inverse metric, respectively: tex2html_wrap_inline3954 , tex2html_wrap_inline3956 , tex2html_wrap_inline3958 . The same thing will be done with tex2html_wrap_inline3960 .

In the presence of torsion, the connection is no longer equal to the Christoffel symbol. In fact, by rewriting tex2html_wrap_inline3962 trivially as

  eqnarray526

and using tex2html_wrap_inline3964 , we find the decomposition

  equation561

where the combination of torsion tensors

  equation569

is called the contortion tensor. It is antisymmetric in the last two indices so that

  equation577

In the presence of torsion, the shortest and straightest lines are no longer equal. Since the two types of lines play geometrically an equally favored role, the question arises as to which of them describes the correct classical particle orbits. The answer will be given at the end of this section.

The main effect of matter in Einstein's theory of gravitation manifests itself in the violation of the integrability condition for the derivative of the coordinate transformation tex2html_wrap_inline3922 , namely,

  equation587

A transformation for which tex2html_wrap_inline3922 itself is integrable, while the first derivatives tex2html_wrap_inline3970 are not, carries a flat-space region into a purely curved one. The quantity which records the nonintegrability is the Cartan curvature tensor

  equation592

Working out the derivatives using (19) we see that tex2html_wrap_inline3972 can be written as a covariant curl of the connection,

  equation600

In the last term we have used a matrix notation for the connection. The tensor components tex2html_wrap_inline3974 are viewed as matrix elements tex2html_wrap_inline3976 , so that we can use the matrix commutator

  equation610

Einstein's original theory of gravity assumes the absence of torsion. The space properties are completely specified by the Riemann curvature tensor formed from the Riemann connection (the Christoffel symbol)

  equation622

The relation between the two curvature tensors is

  equation637

In the last term, the tex2html_wrap_inline3978 's are viewed as matrices tex2html_wrap_inline3980 . The symbols tex2html_wrap_inline3982 denote the covariant derivatives formed with the Christoffel symbol. Covariant derivatives act like ordinary derivatives if they are applied to a scalar field. When applied to a vector field, they act as follows:

  eqnarray654

The effect upon a tensor field is the generalization of this; every index receives a corresponding additive tex2html_wrap_inline3984 contribution.

In the presence of torsion, there exists another covariant derivative formed with the affine connection tex2html_wrap_inline3924 rather than the Christoffel symbol which acts upon a vector field as

  eqnarray666

This will be of use later.

From either of the two curvature tensors, tex2html_wrap_inline3972 and tex2html_wrap_inline3990 , one can form the once-contracted tensors of rank 2, the Ricci tensor

  equation677

and the curvature scalar

  equation683

The celebrated Einstein equation for the gravitational field postulates that the tensor

  equation689

the so-called Einstein tensor, is proportional to the symmetric energy-momentum tensor of all matter fields. This postulate was made only for spaces with no torsion, in which case tex2html_wrap_inline3992 and tex2html_wrap_inline3994 are both symmetric. As mentioned before, it is not yet clear how Einstein's field equations should be generalized in the presence of torsion since the experimental consequences are as yet too small to be observed. In this paper, we are not concerned with the generation of curvature and torsion but only with their consequences upon the motion of point particles.

The generation of defects illustrated in Fig. 1 provides us with two simple examples for nonholonomic mappings which show us in which way these mappings are capable of generating a space with curvature and torsion from a euclidean space.   The reader not familiar with this subject is advised to consult the standard literature on this subject quoted in Ref. [8, 9].

Consider first the upper example in which a dislocation is generated, characterized by a missing or additional layer of atoms (see Fig. 10.1). In two dimensions, it may be described differentially by the transformation

  equation707

with the multi-valued function

  equation715

The triads reduce to dyads, with the components

  eqnarray718

and the torsion tensor has the components

  equation726

If we differentiate (44) formally, we find tex2html_wrap_inline4000 . This, however, is incorrect at the origin. Using Stokes'  theorem we see that

  equation736

for any closed circuit around the origin, implying that there is a tex2html_wrap_inline4002 -function singularity at the origin with

  equation739

By a linear superposition of such mappings we can generate an arbitrary torsion in the q-space. The mapping introduces no curvature. When encircling a dislocation along a closed path C, its counter image C' in the ideal crystal does not form a closed path. The closure failure is called the Burgers vector

  equation749

It specifies the direction and thickness of the layer of additional atoms. With the help of Stokes' theorem, it is seen to measure the torsion contained in any surface S spanned by C:

  eqnarray755

where tex2html_wrap_inline4014 is the projection of an oriented infinitesimal area element onto the plane tex2html_wrap_inline4016 . The above example has the Burgers vector

  equation765

A corresponding closure failure appears when mapping a closed contour C in the ideal crystal into a crystal containing a dislocation. This defines a Burgers vector:

  equation769

By Stokes' theorem, this becomes a surface integral

  eqnarray775

the last step following from (20).

The second example is the nonholonomic mapping in the lower part of Fig. 1 generating a disclination which corresponds to an entire section of angle tex2html_wrap_inline4020 missing in an ideal atomic array. For an infinitesimal angel tex2html_wrap_inline4020 , this may be described, in two dimensions, by the differential mapping

  equation790

with the multi-valued function (44). The symbol tex2html_wrap_inline4024 denotes the antisymmetric Levi-Cività tensor. The transformed metric

  equation799

is single-valued and has commuting derivatives. The torsion tensor vanishes since tex2html_wrap_inline4026 is proportional to tex2html_wrap_inline4028 . The local rotation field tex2html_wrap_inline4030 , on the other hand, is equal to the multi-valued function tex2html_wrap_inline4032 , thus having the noncommuting derivatives:

  equation818

To lowest order in tex2html_wrap_inline4034 , this determines the curvature tensor, which in two dimensions posses only one independent component, for instance tex2html_wrap_inline4036 . Using the fact that tex2html_wrap_inline3910 has commuting derivatives, tex2html_wrap_inline4036 can be written as

  equation825


next up previous
Next: New Equivalence Principle Up: Classical Motion of a Previous: Equations of Motion

Hagen Kleinert
Thu Aug 8 08:53:22 MET DST 1996